**Substantial evidence** is [[Glossary/E/Evidence|evidence]] capable of reasonably supporting a factual finding under the applicable standard. On [[Glossary/A/Appeal|appeal]], substantial-evidence review asks whether the record supports the finding, rather than whether the reviewing judges would have reached the same factual conclusion themselves. ## In California Family Law An appellate challenge to a family court's factual findings must be distinguished from a challenge to its legal reasoning or exercise of discretion. The issue being reviewed determines the standard. [[De Novo|De novo]] review and [[Abuse of Discretion|abuse of discretion]] review serve different functions; not every issue in the same appeal necessarily receives the same treatment. Under substantial-evidence review, the appellate court generally defers to the fact-finder's resolution of conflicting evidence and witness credibility. The existence of evidence favoring the appellant does not by itself require reversal. ## The Trial Burden Still Matters When the challenged finding required clear and convincing proof, that burden does not disappear on appeal. In [Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989](https://law.justia.com/cases/california/supreme-court/2020/s254938.html), the California Supreme Court explained that review must account for whether a reasonable fact-finder could have found the fact highly probable, while respecting the trial court's credibility assessments and reasonable inferences. This is not permission to affirm a finding without adequate evidentiary support. It is also not a substitute for identifying the actual finding, required burden of proof and relevant record. ## Example A family court hears conflicting [[Glossary/T/Testimony|testimony]] and makes a factual finding in favor of one parent. On appeal, the other parent cannot obtain reversal merely by repeating the testimony that favored their own account. The challenge must address the governing standard and the record supporting the finding, including any heightened burden that applied.